Home / Resources / Search Console checkup

Guide · Do it yourself

The 15-minute monthly Search Console checkup

Google Search Console tells you what people searched before they found you, which pages are working, and which pages Google left out. Most owners set it up once and never open it again. This is the short monthly routine that turns it into decisions: what to rewrite, what to build and what to fix.

The short version

  • Once a month, open the Performance report and compare the last 28 days to the previous 28 days.
  • In the Queries tab, look for two things: searches where you show up a lot but few people click, and searches you show up for with no page that answers them.
  • In the Pages tab, find the pages that lost the most clicks.
  • Glance at the Page indexing and Sitemaps reports. Only act when an important page is missing.
  • Write it all in a simple log so next month you can see what changed and why.

Haven't set up Search Console yet? Start with How to get Google, Bing and ChatGPT to find your new website, then come back.

Monthly · 2 minutes

1. Open the Performance report and compare two 28-day periods

Sign in at search.google.com/search-console and pick your site. In the left menu, open Performance, then Search results.

By default, the report shows the past three months. That's too long to spot what changed recently. Change it:

  1. Click the date filter at the top of the report.
  2. Choose Compare.
  3. Pick the last 28 days against the previous 28 days, then apply.
  4. Above the chart, turn on all four metrics: Total clicks, Total impressions, Average CTR and Average position.

Now the chart shows two lines for each metric, and the table below gets a Difference column. That column does most of the work in the next steps.

Why 28 days? It holds exactly four of each weekday. A slow Sunday in one period is matched by a slow Sunday in the other, so the comparison stays fair.

Monthly · 2 minutes

2. Read the four numbers

Here is what each one means, in plain words.

  • Clicks: how many times someone clicked through to your site from Google Search. This is the number closest to real visitors.
  • Impressions: how many times your site appeared in search results, whether or not anyone clicked. Think of it as how often Google put you in front of people.
  • CTR (click-through rate): clicks divided by impressions. Of the people who saw you, the share who chose you.
  • Average position: on average, how high your top result appeared. Position 1 is the top. Lower numbers are better.

Read them together, not alone. A few common patterns:

  • Impressions up, clicks flat: Google is testing you for more searches, but your listing isn't convincing yet. Step 3 is for you.
  • Impressions and clicks both down: often seasonal, or you lost ground on a few searches. Step 5 will show which pages.
  • Clicks up, average position worse: usually fine. You started appearing for new, broader searches where you rank lower, which pulls the average down.
Monthly · 3 minutes

3. Find searches with many impressions but few clicks

Click the Queries tab under the chart. Each row is a search people typed before your site appeared.

  1. Click the Impressions column header to sort from most to fewest.
  2. Scan the top 20 rows. Look for searches with lots of impressions but few clicks, compared with your other searches.
  3. Ignore rows where your average position is far down the results (say, past the first page). Few people scroll that far, so a low CTR there is expected.
  4. For each search worth winning, click the row, then open the Pages tab. That shows which page Google is showing for it.

That page is your rewrite target. People saw it and passed. Usually the title or description didn't match what they were looking for. Rewrite both:

  • Title: say plainly what the page offers and where. Google recommends descriptive, concise titles, unique to each page, with no repeated keywords. "Water heater repair in Fruitvale | Your Company" beats "Home."
  • Meta description: a short, specific summary that answers "is this what I'm looking for?" Google writes most snippets from the page itself, but may use your description when it describes the page better.
  • The first paragraph: make sure the page answers the search right away. Since Google often pulls the snippet from page text, a clear opening helps twice.

Change one or two pages a month, not ten. Then you can tell what worked when you compare next month.

Monthly · 2 minutes

4. Find searches you have no page for

Stay in the Queries tab, and read further down the list. You will find searches you show up for even though no page on your site really answers them. Google matched you on a passing mention, a blog post or your homepage.

Signs you have a gap:

  • The search names a service, a neighborhood or a question you don't have a page about.
  • When you click the row and open the Pages tab, Google is showing your homepage or an unrelated page.
  • Several similar searches cluster around the same topic, like a service plus three nearby towns.

Each real gap is a page to build. If people search "tankless water heater install" plus your town and you only mention it in a list, a dedicated page has a much better chance of earning the click. Our guide to service pages that get found covers how to write one.

Only build pages for searches that match what you actually do. A page that exists only to catch traffic you can't serve won't help you.

A real example This is exactly how I decide what to build on ChiroTrack, my chiropractic education site. I read the Queries tab to see which searches about specific chiropractic schools and the cost of chiropractic school were already showing the site. Where people were searching and no page truly answered them, those became the school and cost pages I built next. Search Console told me what people wanted before I spent time writing.
Monthly · 2 minutes

5. Find pages that slipped

Click the Pages tab under the chart. With compare mode still on, each page shows clicks for both periods and the difference.

  1. Sort by the Difference column for clicks, so the biggest losses rise to the top.
  2. Look at the top three or four. Is this a page that matters, like a main service page, a location page or your contact page?
  3. Click the page, then open the Queries tab. Which searches did it lose?

Common reasons a page slips, and what to do:

  • Seasonal demand: impressions fell along with clicks for the whole site. Nothing to fix. Compare with the same month last year if you have the data.
  • You changed the page: a new title, a redesign or a changed address can all shift results. Check that the page still answers the search clearly.
  • A competitor got better: search for the main query yourself and look at who now ranks above you. Is their page more useful, more specific or more current?
  • The page fell out of the index: check it in step 6.

Also glance at the pages that gained the most. They show you what's working, so you can do more of it.

Monthly · 2 minutes

6. Check the Page indexing report

In the left menu, under Indexing, open Pages. This is the Page indexing report. It splits your known pages into two groups: Indexed (in Google and able to appear) and Not indexed.

Google says plainly that not indexed is not necessarily bad. Your goal is simple: every page you want people to find should be indexed. The rest can stay out. Scroll to the Why pages aren't indexed table and read the reasons. Here are the ones you'll see most:

  • Crawled - currently not indexed: Google read the page and chose not to add it, for now. Google says there's no need to resubmit it. Make the page more useful and clearly different from your other pages, and link to it from your menu or a related page.
  • Discovered - currently not indexed: Google knows the page exists but hasn't visited it yet. On a new site this is normal. Link to the page from pages that are already indexed and give it time.
  • URL marked 'noindex': the page tells Google to leave it out. If you meant that (a thank-you page, a private page), good. If not, remove the noindex setting. In WordPress, check your SEO plugin's setting for that page.
  • Not found (404): the page doesn't exist. That's fine if you deleted it on purpose with no replacement. If the page moved, set up a 301 redirect from the old address to the new one.
  • Page with redirect and Alternate page with proper canonical tag: usually nothing to do. Google indexed the page these point to.
  • Duplicate without user-selected canonical: Google sees this page as a copy of another one and picked the other. If the two pages should be different, make their content clearly different.

Once a month, check two things only. Is the indexed count steady or rising? And is any important page on the not-indexed list? To check a single page, paste its address into the search bar at the top of Search Console. That's the URL Inspection tool.

After you fix a real problem, open that reason's row and click Validate fix. Google says validation can take about two weeks, sometimes longer, so don't click it twice.

Monthly · 1 minute

7. Check your sitemap status

In the left menu, open Sitemaps. Each sitemap you submitted shows a status:

  • Success: Google read it without errors. You're done.
  • Has errors: Google read part of it. Click the row to see which errors, and send them to whoever manages your site.
  • Couldn't fetch: Google couldn't get the file at all. Open the sitemap address in your browser. If it doesn't load, that's the problem. If it does load, check that your robots.txt isn't blocking it.

Also look at Last read and Discovered pages. If you added pages this month, the discovered count should go up. If you made big changes, you can resubmit. Otherwise Google rereads it on its own schedule.

Monthly · 1 minute

8. Write it down in your monthly log

The checkup only pays off if you can compare months. Keep a spreadsheet, or a note on your phone, with one row per month. Use these columns:

Monthly log template

  1. Date of the checkup.
  2. Clicks for the last 28 days, and the change from the previous 28.
  3. Impressions for the last 28 days, and the change.
  4. Top 5 queries by clicks, written out word for word.
  5. Pages improved this month, and what you changed (title, description, first paragraph).
  6. Pages added this month, and the search each one is meant to answer.

After three or four months, the log tells a story. You'll see whether a rewritten title earned more clicks, and whether a new page started showing up. That's how you learn what works for your business, not someone else's.

What to ignore

Search Console has a lot of numbers. Most of them don't need your attention every month.

  • Small day-to-day swings. One busy day or one slow day means nothing. That's why you compare 28-day periods. Google also notes the newest data can be preliminary and may change.
  • Average position on its own. It's an average across every search you appear for. When you start showing up for new searches, it often gets worse even as clicks grow. Read it next to clicks and impressions, never alone.
  • Searching for yourself. Google tailors results by place, device and history. What you see on your phone isn't what a customer across town sees.
  • Chart and table totals that don't match. Google counts them in slightly different ways. It's normal.
  • Every not-indexed page. Only important pages matter.

For a small site, Google itself says you may not need the Page indexing report much at all. The Performance report is where the useful decisions come from.

The 15-minute monthly checklist

  1. Performance → Search results. Compare the last 28 days to the previous 28.
  2. Note clicks, impressions, CTR and average position. Read them together.
  3. Queries tab: pick one or two searches with many impressions and few clicks. Rewrite that page's title and description.
  4. Queries tab: note any search with no matching page. Add it to your build list.
  5. Pages tab: sort by click difference. Find out why the top losers slipped.
  6. Indexing → Pages: confirm your important pages are indexed.
  7. Sitemaps: confirm the status says Success.
  8. Fill in this month's row in your log.

Common questions

Why compare 28 days instead of one week?

A 28-day window holds exactly four of each weekday, so a slow Sunday or a holiday Monday doesn't skew the comparison. A single week is too small for most local businesses to see a real trend.

My clicks dropped this month. Should I panic?

Not yet. Check whether impressions dropped too, which usually means a seasonal dip or a ranking change. Then look at the Pages tab to see if one page explains most of the drop. If the drop holds for two months in a row, dig deeper.

Why does a query show in Search Console when I can't find myself for it?

Google personalizes results by time, place, device and search history. You may have appeared for someone else in another neighborhood or on another day. The report is a better guide than searching for yourself.

Should I fix every page listed as not indexed?

No. Google says not indexed is not necessarily bad. Redirects, duplicates, removed pages and pages you hid on purpose belong there. Only act when a page you want people to find is on the list.

How often should I request indexing for a page that was crawled but not indexed?

Usually not at all. Google says there is no need to resubmit those pages. Improve the page and link to it from your other pages instead, then check again next month.

Rather have someone check it for you?

I'll look at how your business shows up on Google, Maps and AI search, and send you a short recorded walkthrough with the three fixes that matter most. It's free, with no obligation.

Get your free visibility audit Take the 3-minute scorecard

Sources

  1. Search Console Help, "Performance report (Search results): Overview and basic setup." support.google.com
  2. Search Console Help, "Performance report (Search results): Advanced filtering and comparison." support.google.com
  3. Search Console Help, "Page indexing report." support.google.com
  4. Search Console Help, "Sitemaps report." support.google.com
  5. Google Search Central, "Influencing title links in Google Search." developers.google.com
  6. Google Search Central, "How to write meta descriptions." developers.google.com

Terms used here are defined in the glossary. To set up Search Console and submit your sitemap, start with How to get Google, Bing and ChatGPT to find your new website. For how Maps and AI tools choose which businesses to name, read How local businesses get found in Google and AI answers, and to see whether AI tools mention you, try the ChatGPT check.

About the author Dr. Ben Glass, DC, has practiced chiropractic in Oakland since 2013 and owns The Shift Chiropractic and Oakland Accident Care. He built and tends the websites and local search for both practices himself, founded ChiroTrack, and now helps local business owners get found online through Glasshouse.